


I’ve played OnLive for close to a week now… And Steam for a few years…
Graphics:
Now this is the killer of OnLive… I could suck up a few of the OnLive problems if the graphics weren’t so crappy. When I saw the Demo for OnLive the graphics were crisp and really nice… But instead… This is just what the menu looks like

and this is what you exspect from the demos

Can’t see the difference? Take a closer look (when it’s full screened you can really see the difference) What I see(non full screen):
View… In the demo (looks like full screen):
View… … Now they can’t even make the text crisp… You can image how bad this plays out when playing a game…. As for Steam, it is the full graphiced game that you would buy in the store… You can change the dimension video setting and other things. As for OnLive you cannot.
Price for the games:
They both cost about the same which in itself is about $10 cheaper than retail in a store such as GameStop. But if you buy through OnLive you only get the game for 3 years and if you stop paying the $14.95 monthly then you cannot play the games you bought.
I will say the price is the same between Steam and OnLive BUT for OnLIve you get the game for 3 years… Now that is a nice length but at the same time I’ve gone back to a game on steam in later years and for me to have to repay FULL price for the game when I could have bought the game forever seems a little sketchy.
How long it takes to actually play the game (Downloading):
I really don’t mind personally waiting an half an hour to an hour for a game to download on average 1.2 mbps while I go do something or go play another game on Steam (though sometimes the download will stop if you start playing another Steam game while a game is downloading.) But it is nice to instantly play a game on OnLive. No downloading. No waiting. Just hit enter and play. So I will give this one to OnLive for how quickly you can Play the Game.
Accessory Support:
Now for me I’m on a mac and I am using an IntelliMouse Explorer 4 which is somehow not supported in OnLive… and if I may speak for a lot of gamers… To play a shooter without a mouse and/or using a trackpad is really not something I like. And they have updated the client and still haven’t supported my mouse.. Now I’m sure my mouse isn’t the only one but it is kind of odd. My mouse works fine in the menu but once I get into a game my mouse just doesn’t work. As for Steam anything your computer can recognize so can steam. Steam doesn’t in and of itself stop you from using any accessory that is supported in the game
Hack-Proof:
OnLive says their product is really hard to hack, and I’ve found that it is. So good for them, though I guess anything’s possible. As for Steam of course it has been out longer but it has been hacked and mod’d (so far that I know of) that kind of give the OnLive an advantage for them as far as they can’t really lose money by people stealing games. I mean, if everything is on another server running on their computers, and then your account is hooked up to another server with all of the data of what you own and information, then again it is not impossible. I think it might just be a while before there is a hack for OnLive.
Demo:
Now this is something that is really nice. Since OnLive is instant playing you can do a 30 minute demo of most games (but not all). As for Steam, you can watch a trailer… Look up some gameplay… Or wait for a free weekend of the game… Even so, there are hardly any demos if any for Steam.
Community:
In January 2010 Valve (Steam) claimed that it had surpassed 25 million active user accounts. As for OnLive it hasn’t been out that long so there aren’t really numbers yet but I don’t think it’s that close to Steam. And I don’t think it ever will be. There isn’t much of a “Community” in OnLive…Yeah, you can watch other people show off their cool movies and send people/friends messages, but in Steam you have Clans, Friends, Live chats, Voice Chat and other “Community”- like things.
Now this is what really matters… How many games does each have?
There are over 1,100 games available through Steam and 11 games on OnLive now I know this isn’t completely fair for OnLive but I will say OnLive will never surpass the amount of Games Steam has. When a game comes out for OnLive it either was already on Steam or is coming out for Steam… Plus it’s going to take a while for OnLive to get to that number if they last that long.
Online Games:
Most games on Steam are online… It is really great to be able to play in hundreds of servers around the world with hardly any lag talking to people and playing games with them. As for Onlive there aren’t any really “play with other people” games which is kind of annoying. So I will of course have to give Steam this one for online games which is really something that is important.
Accessibility:
I will give each a check because: 1) onlive opens instantly and you don’t have to wait for a game to download but at the same time you can’t play anywhere… for steam you can play offline but you do have to download the games… and update the games as well as take the time to open the client.
Price (for the software):
Steam is free; there is no monthly fee for having the software or any extra cost for the game. In fact a lot of the games are cheaper than you would have to pay if you bought them in real life. But you do have to use their software to play the game which isn’t always a bad thing. As for OnLive it is a $14.95 a month (I like to say $15 a month) and you don’t get all the games for free you still have to buy the games you want. Which is kind of a bummer. But they did do a 1 year trial if you registered before it came out so most people have the first year free but after that it’s a $14.99 a month. So if you stop paying you can’t play the games you bought!
Length of purchase…
Like I said steam you keep the game forever… as for onlive not so much plus on average they are the same price… As far as online goes… Now there is always the problem of steam closing making you not able to play the game anymore.. or if steam is nice just not online but you can have them offline.. as for OnLive… if onlive closes you can never play the game again as well as there is no way to get the game.. But for both of these they have there faults compaired to paying 10 extra bucks to get a CD and have the game forever.
Impact on how people will play games:
Playing games is a huge part of getting a video game as I’m sure you can imagine. As as far as that OnLive has the edge on that. To be able to instantly play a brag clip of someone playing it, then you demoing it for 30 minutes, and then you instantly playing it seems pretty awesome. As opposed to Steam where you can watch a trailer about the game, then buy it, then wait about an hour for it to download, and then play the game. If OnLive had the Quality of Steam I think it could really be something great.
Impact on how people will buy games:
They both have their impacts in different ways… As for OnLive, you hit the Buy button, accept, and you’re in the game… For steam a few more steps but the same rule you buy the game if you have a credit card on file like OnLive you just purchase and DOWNLOAD which OnLive you do not have to do.
Breakthrough in the market:
Now I love how OnLive works. You find the game you want… You hit it then you play… No downloading, no nothing. Instantly streaming it, which is really a nice thing rather than waiting an hour to download a game and then playing it.
Summery
I think OnLive is a great idea, but the technology and the internet speed just isn’t there yet. Like a lot of new things it has a lot of problems I am sure they will fix later on. But Steam has been out there for a while and they got everything done. Sure every now and then a minor bug will come out but they already have a brand, a service, and they’re doing a great job. First impressions really matter and I think OnLive didn’t really pull it off. As far as computer gaming goes I will still have to go with Steam. Maybe someday they will partner up or something and have a monthly fee for Steam if you want to use there “OnLive” service but for now I think you can take your chances with OnLive and hope for the best and suffer through the next hopefully only few months of bad bugs and bad graphics and hardware problems and I’m sure many other things. Or you can sit back and use Steam which has a lot of the big issues taken care of and let OnLive hopefully get fixed while you playing a full game with best graphics, and hardware supported.
Share on digg
VN:F [1.9.13_1145]
Rating: 6.2/10 (13 votes cast)
VN:F [1.9.13_1145]